Review: Airship Pirates

Introduction

Airship Pirates is either a work of genius or a foolhardy and doomed endeavour. Steampunk is big, yes, but it’s still a subculture and this isn’t just a Steampunk RPG its an RPG tied to a particular Steampunk band – Abney Park. There’s a risk, then, that this game could be passed over by people who aren’t simultaneously RPG fans, Steampunk fans and Abney Park fans. That’s a bit of a tall order. That said, subcultural ties worked out great for Vampire.

Background

Something has gone wrong with time and the world has changed, peculiarly. Down on the surface things are a bit post-apocalyptic, up in the air and in mountaintop cities things are all a bit neo-victorian and mighty airships ply the skies, well above the dangerous chrono-fused plains, wastes and jungles below where all manner of monstrous creatures from Earth’s past are wandering around. An oppressive Empire, a wild and dangerous world and airships cruising the skies. It’s a ripe world for air piracy, plunder, adventure, freedom fighting and maybe, even, making things better or worse by tinkering with time yourselves.

Mechanics

Airship Pirates uses the Heresy game engine, which is the same game engine used for Victoriana. While there are a few changes here and there it’s almost entirely compatible with Victoriana – which could make things quite interesting – and thus has the same little rules oddities that Victoriana has, namely the use of both negative dice (chance of reducing successes) and reduction in dice pool which, statistically, amounts to almost the same thing and seems needlessly finicky.

Where Airship Pirates advances the system is, in particular, with the design and customisation of airships which is hardly surprising, given the name of the game, but which could provide a sound basis for the design of vehicles and devices in Victoriana and anything else that comes along using the Heresy system.

Atmosphere

I’m not that familiar with Abney Park being more of a Vernian Process man myself but the game clearly draws quite strongly on the imaginations, costuming, music and lyrics of the chaps and chapettes of Abney Park. The book is full colour, though this pretty much means ‘sepia’! The stories and quoted lyrics do paint a picture but much of the book is, thankfully, a fairly straightforward and unobfuscated world guide.

Personally I was a little disappointed it was concentrated on America, but the bally Abney Park people are filthy colonials and I suppose it gives one room to carve a little bit of the world out for oneself. Many of the ideas presented compensate for yankee parochialism, pirates and aerial cities for just two.

Artwork

It’s hard to nail down exactly what to say about the art. There’s a mix of styles and competencies on display but it’s all appropriate and the eclectic mix of material fits the chronologically kerjiggered nature of the setting. I don’t know if it would necessarily work in another game or setting but it works here.

Conclusion

The genius of this game is that due to all the temporal flux and reality issues going on characters could be crossed over between people’s games, taken and played at – for example – convention games and then going back to their home games. I wish there was a Heresy LARP system because with the crafting/costuming talent and effort of the Steampunk community some LARP events and groups could really accomplish something special and there’s not necessarily any need for them all to jibe perfectly together.

On the plus side

  • Pirates!
  • Airships!
  • Accessible vehicle rules.

On the minus side

  • Tied to a relatively obscure band mythology.
  • Heresy system quirks.
  • ‘Impure’ genre

Score

Style: 4
Substance: 4
Overall: 4

6 responses to “Review: Airship Pirates

  1. Incidentally, the images used in this review, as well as a plethora of other art we did for the Airship Pirates book, are available in our Etsy store. (See website link.) ^_^

    ~MANDEM

  2. It must be noted that this review is horribly lacking in proper research as well as highly opinionated. Steampunk is also much more widely spread than this reviewer thinks, the Steampunk community numbers in thousands, possibly more.

    • Thousands isn’t very many. When reviewing a product you review what’s there in the product. Given this was a good review (essentially 8/10) it’s hard to see what the fuss is about. The only other review that’s gotten such a ARGLBARGLEFARGLE reaction was the one about the last edition of Twilight 2000 and one suspects – forgive me – that a similar fanboy issue is at hand here.

    • That really isn’t that many, all things considered. A niche game appealing to a niche group within a niche subculture is a risky venture – though it can work fine. FYI I wrote one of the first Steampunk RPGs available on the internet (Iron Empire) and have been interested in the genre for a very long time. I understand subcultural pride and defensiveness but given this was a positive review the level of snark and overreaction is… curious and bewildering. As to research, when you review a product… you review the product.

  3. I’m sorry, but I can’t trust critics. I have over 17 years experience in the weapons industry, and every person who tests a weapon (except for one) always says “It’s the best weapon I ever shot.” And then, don’t forget the great movie critics. Case in point, “The English Patient”. Opening day, all the critics bashed it. The very next day, they recanted their opinions. I have found that if you want an honest opinion, ask your customers. They don’t pull punches, and they can tell you what they like and dislike better than those who feel they have the almighty, powerful, final word.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s